Medications Aren't the Enemy. Guesswork Is.

Why testing your brain chemistry turns trial-and-error into precision care

We’ve built a culture of extremes, especially when it comes to health.

On one side are those who believe natural automatically means better, swearing off anything that comes in a capsule or prescription pad. On the other are those who dismiss nutrition, supplements, and lifestyle as “woo woo,” clinging to the belief that only pharmaceuticals are real medicine.

Neither side has it completely right. And both miss something crucial: the body isn’t loyal to ideology — it’s loyal to chemistry.

That polarization shows up clearly in the ADHD world. One camp says “just eat cleaner.” The other says “just medicate it.” Meanwhile, patients bounce between both, wondering why they still don’t feel like themselves.

In my clinical experience, I’ve seen medication transform lives when guided by data — and completely derail them when chemistry is ignored. Functional medicine often preaches “food first,” but when neurotransmitters are deeply depleted or misfiring, even the cleanest diet won’t rewire signaling overnight. Telling someone with low dopamine, poor focus, and emotional instability to suddenly go gluten-free, dairy-free, corn-free, and nut-free is like asking a musician to play a concerto on a broken instrument. When the brain doesn’t feel good, executive function is impaired — meal prep, planning, and willpower are compromised.

Sometimes the first step isn’t dietary restriction; it’s biochemical scaffolding — restoring neurotransmitter balance so the brain has enough signal, safety, and stability to engage in change. That scaffolding can look different for everyone. For some, it’s targeted amino acid therapy that replenishes precursors and stabilizes mood naturally. For others, it’s temporary medication support — or even a combination of both. The goal isn’t to label one “good” and the other “bad,” but to get the brain feeling well enough that diet and lifestyle shifts stop feeling impossible.

That’s where urine testing comes in — not as a replacement for psychiatry, but as its missing partner. By mapping neurotransmitters and their metabolites in urine, we can see how dopamine, serotonin, norepinephrine, and glutamate are behaving in the body. It involves a simple, in-home urine test- no needles, no hassle, just clarity. This data doesn’t diagnose, but it does reveal direction — showing whether a stimulant, an SSRI, or a mood stabilizer might align with a person’s unique neurochemistry rather than work against it.

Because the goal isn’t “I did it with no meds.”

The goal is true healing — restoring balance through systems biology, using whatever tools help the brain and body remember how to work in harmony again.

And that’s really what it comes down to — harmony.

Your neurotransmitters are the instruments in your brain’s symphony. Dopamine keeps tempo, norepinephrine adds intensity, serotonin softens the tone, GABA calms the rhythm, and glutamate drives the melody forward. When one section plays too loud or too soft, the entire song of your attention, motivation, and mood shifts out of tune.

The Chemical Choreography Behind ADHD

ADHD isn’t just about focus — it’s about signaling. The condition we label as “attention deficit” is really a story of how those instruments communicate, how well they follow the conductor, and how balanced the performance feels.

When dopamine and norepinephrine lag behind, the tempo drops — motivation and focus fade. When serotonin or GABA are depleted, emotional regulation falters. And when glutamate runs wild, the brain’s soundboard distorts into static: racing thoughts, impulsivity, and overwhelm.

That’s why two people can share the same diagnosis yet respond completely differently to the same medication. One may feel calm and composed; another, jittery and detached. The difference isn’t willpower — it’s wiring.

Why the Same Medication Feels So Different in Different Brains

When we understand the brain as a symphony, medication becomes a tuning tool — not a volume knob.

A stimulant doesn’t create dopamine; it just amplifies the notes already being played. But if your serotonin section is overactive or your GABA strings are too quiet, the music can quickly turn into noise.

That’s why one person takes a stimulant and feels laser-focused, while another feels anxious or numb. The medication didn’t “fail” — it amplified the wrong frequency.

Every brain has a unique composition of neurotransmitters and metabolites. Some people burn through dopamine too quickly (we see this in high HVA turnover), others over-convert serotonin to 5-HIAA, leaving them emotionally flat. High norepinephrine turnover can make a person tense and wired, while low GABA or high glutamate can make emotional regulation feel like a broken metronome.

Medication responses make far more sense when you know which instruments are out of tune.

When clinicians can see this data, the “trial-and-error” approach becomes unnecessary. Instead of guessing which medication might help, we can identify which biochemical notes need tuning — and choose accordingly.

Seeing the Score: What Neurotransmitter Testing Reveals

Urine neurotransmitter testing offers a window into how the brain and body are actually communicating. It’s not about chasing numbers — it’s about seeing patterns: which signals are firing too fast, which are lagging behind, and where the system has lost its rhythm.

A simple urine sample can reveal how key messengers are behaving — dopamine and its metabolite HVA, norepinephrine’s VMA, serotonin’s 5-HIAA, and metabolites along the kynurenine pathway, which links inflammation to mood and focus. No test can read the brain directly, but these markers tell us where the traffic is heavy, where it’s stalled, and what may be driving that imbalance.

Unfortunately, even the functional medicine world can get lost in the weeds here — trading prescriptions for supplement protocols and collecting expensive tests like trading cards. It’s still reductionism, just dressed in wellness branding. The goal isn’t another pill, whether it’s synthetic or botanical. The goal is to understand the pattern — how stress, chemistry, nutrient status, gut health, and neural signaling are interacting — and then to change the whole system that produced it.

That’s where this kind of testing truly shines: as a tool for context, not control. It guides us toward targeted nutrition, nervous-system regulation, and smarter collaboration with prescribers — not away from them.

Functional + Conventional: The Partnership We Need

Psychiatry has powerful tools — but too often, it operates in the dark. Functional medicine has the right curiosity — but sometimes, it chases perfection in a Petri dish. The real opportunity is in the middle.

When psychiatrists and functional clinicians work together, the conversation shifts from “What med should we try?” or “What supplement should we add?” to “Why is this system behaving this way?” That’s where progress begins.

In the conventional model, neurotransmitter-related symptoms are managed by prescribing — a top-down approach focused on symptom control. In functional medicine, the same symptoms are managed by a supplement protocol — a bottom-up approach that stacks supplements to push biochemistry in one direction or another.

Both can help. But both can also miss the point.

Neither approach truly heals unless we understand how the whole network of neurotransmitters, nutrients, inflammation, and stress chemistry are working together.

True progress happens when we move from manipulating individual molecules to rebalancing the system itself. That might include a stimulant or SSRI for one person, amino acid therapy for another, or nervous-system retraining for someone else. I have also witnessed a beautiful duet between medications and amino acid therapy taken together. The intervention doesn’t matter as much as the outcome — to restore communication, coherence, and resilience across the brain-body network.

The NeuroFit Nutrition Perspective

In my NeuroFit Nutrition model, neurotransmitter mapping is part of a bigger story — one that also looks at mitochondrial health, nutrient co-factors, and gut-derived signaling molecules that influence mood and focus. Medication can absolutely fit inside that framework when used strategically and collaboratively.

If you’ve tried ADHD medications that made you feel worse, or if you’ve ever been told, “This is just how your brain works,” know this: there’s nothing broken about you. Your body is simply asking to be understood.

There should be no judgment — and certainly no guilt — if you need medication. Sometimes it’s the bridge that allows the brain to access the tools, therapies, and habits that create lasting change. But the magic happens when we pair the right data with the right intervention, in the right order of operations.

That’s where the breakthroughs live — not in choosing sides, but in choosing sequence. When we start with clarity instead of assumptions, medication becomes a precision tool, nutrition becomes strategic, and the nervous system finally gets the chance to re-learn balance.

The future of ADHD care — and really, of medicine itself — isn’t polarized. It’s personalized. It’s layered. It’s timed.

And that’s the art of systems biology:

using the right tool, for the right brain, at the right time.

That’s not chemistry versus choice.

That’s healing by design.

With love & science,

Nikki

---

References

1. Stahl, S.M. (2021). Essential Psychopharmacology: The Prescriber’s Guide. Cambridge University Press.

2. Boadle-Biber, M.C. (1993). Regulation of serotonin synthesis. Prog. Biophys. Mol. Biol., 60(1).

3. Peatfield, R.C. (2012). Urinary neurotransmitter testing in clinical practice. Med. Hypotheses, 78(6).

4. Casey Means, M.D., et al. (2023). Nutrient and metabolic influences on brain signaling pathways. Cell Metabolism.